The GST/HST: Creating an Integrated Sales Tax in a Federal Country
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11575/sppp.v5i0.42380Abstract
Canada is not a country with a reputation for bold experimentation. However, decades of federal-provincial compromises have successfully disproved the belief that an invoice-credit, destination-based value-added tax (VAT) is unworkable at the subnational level. Canada’s experiences with the GST, as well as with subordinate VATs like the HST and independent vats like the QST, have three important and interlinked consequences for future tax reform in Canada. First, the exact shape of provincial-level taxes is largely irrelevant to the smooth functioning of a federal VAT — although lack of provincial-federal coordination inevitably raises administrative costs. Second, the nature of a subordinate sales tax is extremely important at the provincial level. As the furor over British Columbia’s HST demonstrates, governments can’t ignore voters’ views and must retain the freedom to tailor provincial-level taxes to meet them, even when public opinion leads to suboptimal outcomes. And third, the best way Ottawa can avoid such outcomes is to provide the provinces with critical support and encouragement in the form of administrative and economic assistance. Since the federal government controls Canada’s borders, over which imports and exports flow, and administers its own sales tax, there is plenty of scope for cooperation. This paper traces the history of federal sales taxation, from the first turnover tax in 1920 right up the present-day GST, along with comprehensive examinations of regional sales tax issues in every corner of Canada, making it one of the best available summary treatments of the GST.References
Ainsworth, Richard T. (2007) “Tackling VAT Fraud: Car Flipping and Computer Chips on a Carousel,” Tax Notes International, 46 (3): 267-80.
Alarie, Benjamin and Richard Bird (2011) “Tax Aspects of Canadian Fiscal Federalism,” in G. Bizioli and C. Sacchetto, eds., Tax Aspects of Fiscal Federalism: A Comparative Analysis (Amsterdam: IBFD), pp. 77-134.
Auditor General of Canada (1999) Report of the Auditor General of Canada (Ottawa: Government of Canada).
Baretti, Christian, Bernd Huber and Karl Lichtblau (2000) A Tax on Tax Revenue: The Incentive Effects of Equalizing Transfers: Evidence from Germany (CESifo Working Paper Series, Working Paper No. 333, September).
Bass, Neil E. and Pierre-Pascal Gendron (forthcoming) “Sales Taxation,” in Heather Kerr, Ken McKenzie and Jack Mintz, eds., Tax Policy in Canada (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation).
Battle, Ken (1999) Credit Corrosion: Bracket Creep’s Evil Twin (Caledon Inst. of Social Policy).
Bird, Richard M. (1993) “Federal-Provincial Taxation in Turbulent Times,” Canadian Public Administration, 36 (4): 479-96.
Bird, Richard M. (1994) Where Do We Go From Here? Alternatives to the GST (Toronto: KPMG Centre for Government).
Bird, Richard M. (1994a) “The Cost and Complexity of Canada’s VAT: the GST in International Perspective,” Tax Notes International 8 (1): 37-47.
Bird, Richard M. (2009) “The GST in Canada: Plus Ça Change, Plus C’est la Même Chose?,” Bulletin for International Taxation, 63 (8/9, August-September 2009): 414-23.
Bird, Richard M. (2010) “Visibility and Accountability — Is Tax-Inclusive Pricing a Good Thing?,” Canadian Tax Journal, 58 (1): 63-76.
Bird, Richard M. (2010a) “Central and Subnational VATs in Federal Countries,” in Ehtisham Ahmad and Abdulrazak Al Faris, eds., Fiscal Reforms in the Middle East: The VAT in the Gulf Cooperation Council (Cheltenham UK: Edward Elgar), pp. 38-75.
Bird, Richard M. and Pierre-Pascal Gendron (1998) “Dual VATs and Cross-Border Trade: Two Problems, One Solution?,” International Tax and Public Finance, 5 (3): 429-42.
Bird, Richard M. and Pierre-Pascal Gendron (2007) The VAT in Developing and Transitional Countries (New York: Cambridge University Press).
Bird, Richard M. and Pierre-Pascal Gendron (2010) “Sales Taxes in Canada: The GST-HST-QST-RST ‘System,’” Tax Law Review 63 (3): 517-582.
Bird, Richard M. and Michael Smart (2010) “Assigning State Taxes in a Federal Country: The Case of Australia,” in Melbourne Institute, Australia’s Future Tax and Transfer Policy Conference (Melbourne: Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research), pp. 72-94.
Bird, Richard M. and François Vaillancourt (2006) “Changing With the Times: Success, Failure and Inertia in Canadian Federal Arrangements, 1945-2002,” in Jessica S. Wallack and T. N. Srinivasan, eds., Federalism and Economic Reform: International Perspectives (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), pp. 189-248.
Bird, Richard M., Jorge Martinez-Vazquez and Benno Torgler (2008) “Tax Effort in Developing Countries and High Income Countries: The Impact of Corruption, Voice and Accountability,” Economic Analysis & Policy, 38 (1, 2008): 55-71.
Bird, Richard M., Jack M. Mintz and Thomas A. Wilson (2006) "Coordinating Federal and Provincial Sales Taxes: Lessons from the Canadian Experience," National Tax Journal 59 (4): 889-903.
Boadway, Robin (2011) “Rethinking Tax-Transfer Policy for 21st Century Canada,” in Fred Gorbet and Andrew Sharpe, eds., New Directions for Intelligent Government in Canada (Ottawa: Centre for the Study of Living Standards), 163-204.
Boisvert, Michelle and Wayne R. Thirsk (1994), “Border Taxes, Cross-Border Shopping,and the Differential Incidence of the GST,” Canadian Tax Journal 42: 1276-1293.
Brennan, Geoffrey and James M. Buchanan (1980) The Power to Tax: Analytical Foundations of a Fiscal Constitution (New York: Cambridge University Press)
Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) (2010) Non-commercial Provincial Tax Collection Programs, Memorandum D2-3-6, Ottawa, July.
Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) (2010a) Accounting for the Harmonized Sales Tax, Provincial Sales Tax, Provincial Tobacco Tax and Alcohol Markup/Fee on Casual Importations in the Courier and Commercial Streams, Memorandum D17-1-22, Ottawa, July.
Canada Revenue Agency (2004) Compendium of GST/HST Statistics 2004 Edition (2002 Tax Year).
Canada Revenue Agency (2006) "Audit of GST/HST Visitor and Domestic Rebate Programs," available at www.cra-arc.gc.ca/gncy/ntrnl/2006/rbts-eng.html.
Canadian Tax Foundation (2011) Finances of the Nation 2010 (Toronto).
Chetty, Raj, Adam Looney, and Kory Kroft (2009) “Salience and Taxation: Theory and Evidence,” American Economic Review, 99 (4): 1145-77.
Cnossen, Sjibren (1983) “Harmonization of Indirect Taxes in the EEC,” in Charles E. McLure, Jr., ed., Tax Assignment in Federal Countries (Canberra: ANU Press).
Cnossen, Sjibren (2011) ”Commentary” in Institute for Fiscal Studies, Dimensions of Tax Design: The Mirrlees Review (London: Oxford University Press), 370-386.
Dahlby, Bev (2011) “Reforming the Tax Mix in Canada,” Paper prepared for the 2nd Symposium on Tax and Economic Growth, The School of Public Policy, University of Calgary, November.
Department of Finance (1975) Federal Sales and Excise Taxation, Discussion Paper (Ottawa: Government of Canada, June).
Department of Finance (1977) Report of the Commodity Tax Review Group (Ottawa: Government of Canada, June).
Department of Finance (1982) Proposal to Shift the Federal Sales Tax to the Wholesale Trade Level (Ottawa: Government of Canada, April).
Department of Finance (1983) Report of the Federal Sales Tax Review Committee (Ottawa: Government of Canada, May).
Department of Finance (1987) Tax Reform in 1987: Sales Tax Reform (Ottawa: Department of Finance, June).
Department of Finance (1989) The Goods and Services Tax (Ottawa: Department of Finance, April).
Department of Finance (2011) Fiscal Reference Tables.
Department of Finance (2011a) Tax Expenditures and Evaluations 2009.
Domingue, Richard and Jean Soucy (2000) The Goods and Services Tax: 10 Years Later (Ottawa: Library of Parliament).
Due, John F. (1957) Sales Taxation (Urbana: University of Illinois Press).
Dungan, Peter, Jack Mintz, Finn Poschmann and Thomas Wilson (2008) Growth-Oriented Sales Tax Reform for Ontario: Replacing the Retail Sales Tax with a 7.5 Percent Value-Added Tax, Commentary 273 (Toronto: C. D. Howe Institute, September).
Eccleston, Richard (2007) Taxing Reforms: The Politics of the Consumption Tax in Japan, the United States, Canada and Australia (Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar).
European Commission (2011) A Retrospective Evaluation of Elements of the EU VAT System, Report prepared by Institute for Fiscal Studies, December.
Firth, Michael and Ken McKenzie (2011) The GST and Financial Services: Pausing for Perspective, Paper prepared for the 2nd Symposium on Tax and Economic Growth, The School of Public Policy, University of Calgary, November.
Gendron, Pierre-Pascal (2008) “VAT Treatment of Financial Services: Assessment and Policy Proposal for Developing Countries”, Bulletin for International Taxation 62 (11): 494-506.
Gendron, Pierre-Pascal (2010) “How Should the United States Treat Government Entities, Nonprofit Organizations, and Other Tax-Exempt Bodies Under a VAT?” Tax Law Review 63 (2): 477-508.
Gillespie, W. Irwin (1991) Tax, Borrow and Spend: Financing Federal Spending in Canada, 1867-1990 (Ottawa: Carleton University Press).
Gillespie, W. Irwin (1991a) “How to Create a Tax Burden Where No Tax Burden Exists: A Critical Examination of Grady’s “An Analysis of the Distributional Impact of the Goods and Services Tax,” Canadian Tax Journal 39 (4): 925-36.
Gillis, Malcolm (1985) "Federal Sales Taxation: a Survey of Six Decades of Experience, Critiques, and Reform Proposals," Canadian Tax Journal, 33 (1): 68-98.
Godbout, Luc and Suzie St-Cerny (2011) “Are Consumption Taxes Regressive in Quebec?,” Canadian Tax Journal, 59 (3): 463-93.
Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2008) Value-Added Taxes: Lessons Learned from Other Countries on Compliance Risks, Administrative Costs, Compliance Burden, and Transition (GAO-080566, Washington, April).
Grady, Patrick (1990) "An Analysis of the Distributional Impact of the Goods and Services Tax," 38(5/6) Canadian Tax Journal 38 (5/6): 632-643.
Johnson, James A. (1974) “New Tax Sources and Tax-Sharing for Canadian Municipalities,” in Canadian Tax Foundation, 1973 Conference Report (Toronto), pp. 591-612.
Keen, Michael and Ben Lockwood (2006) "Is the VAT a Money Machine?," National Tax Journal 59 (4): 905-928.
Kenney, Lawrence W. and Stanley L. Winer (2006) “Tax Systems in the World: An Empirical Investigation into the Importance of Tax Bases, Administration Costs, Scale and Political Regime,” International Tax and Public Finance, 13: 181–215.
Kesselman, Jonathan R. (1997) General Payroll Taxes: Economics, Politics, and Design (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation).
Krever, Richard and David White, eds. (2007) GST in Retrospect and Prospect (Wellington: Thomson Brookers Ltd.).
Kuo, Chun-Yan, Thomas C. McGirr, and Satya N. Poddar (1988) “Measuring the Non-Neutralities of Sales and Excise Taxes in Canada,” Canadian Tax Journal, 36: 655-70.
Maynard, Hugh and Jacques Nault (2005) Big Farms, Small Farms: Strategies and Sustainable Agriculture to Fit All Sizes (Ottawa: Agricultural Institute of Canada, September).
McLure, Charles E. (2007) "Harmonizing the RSTs and GST: Lessons for Canada from the Canadian Experience," Tax Notes International, 45 (5): 439-45.
Millar, W. Jack (2010) “The Case for Maintaining Tax-Exclusive Pricing,” Canadian Tax Journal, 58 (1): 77-86.
Mintz, Jack M. (1995) “The Business Transfer Tax as a Consumption Tax,” Tax Notes International, 10 (1): 75-86.
Mintz, Jack M., Thomas A. Wilson and Pierre-Pascal Gendron (1994) “Canada’s GST: Sales Tax Harmonization Is the Key to Simplification,” Tax Notes International, 8: 661-78.
Murrell, David and Weiqui Yu (2000) “The Effect of the Harmonized Sales Tax on Consumer Prices in Atlantic Canada,” Canadian Public Policy 26 (4): 451-460.
New Brunswick Department of Finance (2008) A Discussion Paper on New Brunswick's Tax System (Fredericton: Government of New Brunswick).
OECD (1988) Taxing Consumption (Paris: OECD).
Perry, J. Harvey Perry (1955) Taxes, Tariffs and Subsidies: A History of Canadian Fiscal Development (2 vols.; Toronto: University of Toronto Press).
Poddar, Satya (2010) "Treatment of Housing under VAT," Tax Law Review 63 (2): 443-70.
Report (1940) Report of the Royal Commission on Dominion-Provincial Relations (Ottawa: King's Printer).
Report (1956) Report of the Sales Tax Committee to the Minister of Finance (Ottawa: Queen’s Printer).
Report (1966) Report of the Royal Commission on Taxation (Ottawa: Queen’s Printer).
Robinson, A.J. (1986) The Retail Sales Tax in Canada (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation).
Ruffalo, Anthony M. (2011) “The Hardly Simple Tax: Problems in Implementing the New Place-ofSupply Rules,” Canadian Tax Focus (Canadian Tax Foundation), 1 (2): 9.
Saskatchewan (2005) Final Report of the Saskatchewan Business Tax Review Committee (Regina).
Sherman, David M. (2009) “Tax-Included Pricing for HST – Are We There Yet?,” Canadian Tax Journal, 57 (4) 839-56.
Smart, Michael (2007) Lessons in Harmony: What Experience in the Atlantic Provinces Shows about the Benefits of the Harmonized Sales Tax, Commentary 253 (Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute).
Smart, Michael (2011) Departures from Neutrality in Canada’s Goods and Services Tax, Paper prepared for the 2nd Symposium on Tax and Economic Growth, The School of Public Policy, University of Calgary, November.
Smart, Michael and Richard M. Bird (2009) "The Economic Incidence of Replacing a Retail Sales Tax by a Value-Added Tax: Evidence from Canadian Experience," Canadian Public Policy 35 (1): 85-97.
Smart, Michael and Richard M. Bird (2009a) “The Impact on Investment of Replacing a Retail Sales Tax by a Value-Added Tax: Evidence from Canadian Experience,” National Tax Journal, 62 (4): 591609.
Smart, Michael and Richard M. Bird (2012) “VAT in a Federal System: Lessons from Canada,” Paper for UCLA School of Law/Tax Policy Center of Urban Institute, Conference on Tax Reform Outside the Beltway, Los Angeles, February.
Smith, Michael (1992) The Clean Launch: How Revenue Canada, Customs and Excise Implemented the GST (Ottawa: Canadian Centre for Management Development).
Spiro, Peter S. (1993) “Evidence of a Post-GST Increase in the Underground Economy,” Canadian Tax Journal 41: 247-258.
Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs (1988) Eleventh Report. Minutes of Proceedings and Testimony, Issue Number 147 (Ottawa: House of Commons, March 15).
Standing Committee on Finance (1994) Replacing the GST: Options for Canada (Ottawa: House of Commons, June).
Statistics Canada (1992) Public Finance Historical Data 1965/66-1991/92 (Ottawa: Minister of Industry, Science and Technology).
Tait, Alan A. (1988) Value-Added Tax: International Practice and Problems (Washington: International Monetary Fund).
Vander Ploeg, Casey G. (2011) The Penny Tax: A Timely Tax Innovation to Boost Our Civic Investments (Calgary: Canada West Foundation).
Whalley, John and Deborah Fretz (1990) The Economics of the Goods and Services Tax (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation).
Winer, Stanley L. (2011) “Reflections on the Role of Optimal Design in the Tax Policy Process,” in Fred Gorbet and Andrew Sharpe, eds., New Directions for Intelligent Government in Canada (Ottawa: Centre for the Study of Living Standards), 205-10.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
The following is the copyright statement of SPPP.
Copyright © <Author name> <year>. This is an open-access paper distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons license CC BY-NC 4.0, which allows non-commercial sharing and redistribution so long as the original author and publisher are credited.
Publication Copyright and Licensing
The following guidelines and information, provided in six sections, are intended for authors (the “Author”) who are invited to write a paper (the “Work”) for The School of Public Policy Publications (the “Publisher”). The rights and responsibilities conveyed in the SPP Author Agreement will only apply once your paper is accepted for publication. At that point in the publication process, you will be asked to download the form and return a signed copy via e-mail to spppublications@ucalgary.ca. Please review the below information to ensure agreement with SPPP policies.
Section 1: Author’s Grant of Rights
In consideration of the Publisher’s agreeing to publish the Work in The School of Public Policy Publications, the Author hereby grants to the Publisher the following:
1.1 The irrevocable, royalty-free right to publish, reproduce, publicly display, publicly perform and distribute the Work in perpetuity throughout the world in all means of expression by any method or media now known or hereafter developed, including electronic format;
1.2 The irrevocable, royalty-free right to use the Author’s name and likeness in association with the Work in published form and in advertising and promotional materials related to the Work; and
1.3 The irrevocable, royalty-free right to license others to do any or all of the above.
Section 2: Prior Publication & Publication by Others
2.1 The Author agrees not to publish the Work, or authorize any third party to publish the Work, either in print or electronically, prior to publication of the Work by the Publisher.
2.2 The Author agrees not to publish the Work in any publication outlet which is substantially similar to The School of Public Policy Publications for a period of six (6) months after publication of the Work in The School of Public Policy Publications. Substantially similar is defined as a non-subscription, open-access publication outlet with a similar mandate/vision and intended audience.
2.3 Should the Author publish or distribute the Work elsewhere at any time or in any alternate format, the Author agrees to contact The School of Public Policy Publications to inform them of the subsequent publication.
2.4 Should the Author publish or distribute the Work elsewhere at any time or in any alternate format, the Author agrees to make reasonable efforts to ensure that any such additional publication cites the publication in The School of Public Policy Publications by author, title, and publisher, through a tagline, author bibliography, or similar means. A sample acknowledgement would be:
“Reprinted with permission from the author. Originally published in the The School of Public Policy Publications, http://www.policyschool.ca/publications/.”
Section 3: Editing and Formatting
The Author authorizes the Publisher to edit the Work and to make such modifications as are technically necessary or desirable to exercise the rights in Section 1 in differing media and formats. The Publisher will make no material modification to the content of the Work without the Author’s consent.
Section 4: Author’s Ownership of Copyright and Reservation of Rights
4.1 Nothing in this agreement constitutes a transfer of the copyright by the Author, and the copyright in the Work is subject to the rights granted by this agreement.
4.2 The Author retains the following rights, including but not limited to, the right:
4.2.1 To reproduce and distribute the Work, and to authorize others to reproduce and distribute the Work, in any format;
4.2.2 To post a version of the Work in an institutional repository or the Author’s personal or departmental web page so long as The School of Public Policy Publications is cited as the source of first publication of the Work (see sample acknowledgement above).
4.2.3 To include the Work, in whole or in part, in another work, subject to Section 2 above and provided that The School of Public Policy Publications is cited as the source of first publication of the Work (see sample acknowledgement above).
4.3 The Editors and Editorial Board of The School of Public Policy Publications requires authors to publish the Work under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence (CC BY-NC 4.0). This license allows others to distribute, remix, tweak, and build upon the Work for noncommercial purposes, and ensures the Author is credited for the original creation. This onward licensing is subject to section 2.4 of this agreement, which further ensures that the original publisher is credited.
Section 5: Author’s Warranties and Undertakings
The Author warrants that:
5.1 The Author is the sole author of the Work, or if a joint author, the Author has identified within the Work the other authors, and holds the copyright, either solely or jointly, and has the power to convey the rights granted in this agreement.
5.2 The Work has not previously been published, in whole or in part, except as follows:
5.3 Any textual, graphic or multimedia material included in the Work that is the property or work of another is either explicitly identified by source and cited in the Work or is otherwise identified as follows:
5.4 To the best of the Author’s knowledge, the Work does not contain matter that is obscene, libelous, or defamatory; it does not violate another’s civil right, right of privacy, right of publicity, or other legal right; and it is otherwise not unlawful.
5.5 To the best of the Author’s knowledge, the Work does not infringe the copyright or other intellectual property or literary rights of another.
5.6 The Author will indemnify and hold Publisher harmless against loss, damages, expenses, awards, and judgments arising from breach of any such warranties.
Section 6: The Reuse of Third-Party Works
The Publisher requires that the Author determine, prior to publication, whether it is necessary to obtain permissions from any third party who holds rights with respect to any photographs, illustrations, drawings, text, or any other material (“third-party work”) to be published with or in connection with your Work. Copyright permission will not be necessary if the use is determined to be fair dealing, if the work is in the public domain, or if the rights-holder has granted a Creative Commons or other licence. If either the Author or Publisher determines for any reason that permission is required to include any thirdparty work, the Author will obtain written permission from the rightsholder.
